SiteLock

RV Reviews: Model & Factory Ratings & RV Comparison Guides

Find RV Reviews & RV Ratings for Models, Brands & Manufacturers. RV Comparison Guides, Buying Tips for Travel Trailers, Motorhomes & 5th Wheels. Find Best RVs at Lowest Prices.

  • Home
  • Travel Trailer & Fifth Wheels
  • Motorhomes
  • Truck Campers
  • Lightweights & Pop-Ups
  • RV Model Reports
  • Pre-Purchase Checklist
  • RV Extended Warranties
  • All Products
    • Motorhome Guides
    • Travel Trailer, 5th Wheel & Toy Hauler Comparison Guide
    • Truck Camper Comparison Guide
    • Lightweight Travel Trailer Comparison Guide
    • Pre-Purchase Inspection Checklist
    • Shop RV Reports
    • Combo Order Packages
    • RV Buying Guides
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • About RV Reviews
  • Contact

Everyone is asking us about Pig Urine…

April 28, 2015 By MrRV

Our web gurus track the number of people that read my articles and they always tell me an intriguing title will catch the reader’s eye. I’m going to bet that this week’s title breaks the record for grabbing attention. I’ll let you know the results next week.

Pig Urine really is the talk of the RV town lately. Let me explain.

Most new Motorhome diesel engines now have a special tank that holds Diesel Exhaust Fluid (or DEF). This fluid is composed of Urea and deionized water. Pig urine (or cow, horse, even human) is largely urea and many people refer to DEF as pig urine even though the majority of DEF on the market is not made using animal byproducts. Regardless, the name has stuck.

The addition of the DEF tank to your motorhome engine enables the exhaust to be “scrubbed” with a mixture of DEF and air and the resultant emission is converted from noxious fumes to harmless nitrogen and water. Sounds like a good idea, huh?

It is -but there are concerns…

DEF adds another step to your maintenance process. And it’s an important one. You really don’t want your DEF tank to run dry on a long trip. Resultant repairs are in the $12,000 range. Many of today’s new motorhomes have an added dash gauge, similar to the fuel gauge but some owners don’t like the thought of another thing to keep an eye on. The good news is your motorhome sips DEF (unlike diesel) and a full tank should last thousands of miles. However, if you run low your engine might automatically shut down or refuse to turn over in a self-preservation move. Don’t forget to pack a fresh bottle of DEF for the trip.

Fresh bottle? Yep. There is a shelf life to DEF and each container shows an expiration date. This makes it difficult to just toss a bottle in the storage compartment and forget it. You have to keep an eye on the date and replace it when necessary. Again, not a huge deal but definitely another important step.

DEF FillSome tanks fill at the pump island at truck stops now, just like fuel. Convenient, yes, but don’t top off both tanks while distracted. Mistakenly introducing DEF directly to your fuel tank produces a concrete-like mixture inside your engine and I think that would adversely affect your performance. Apparently enough owners have done it, though, that many Motorhome manufacturers now make a point of placing the fuel and DEF fill points at opposite ends (and even opposite sides) of the vehicle to avoid confusion. It works but now you may have to fill your fuel tank, move the vehicle to the other side of the fuel pumps, and then top off your DEF. Inconvenient, yes, and trying it with a 35’ Motorhome at a busy truck stop probably won’t be fun –or earn you any new friends from those waiting behind you. You can carry a few gallons with you for situations like this but, again, another step.

DEF also freezes and when it’s frozen it obviously can’t be introduced to the exhaust. The freeze point for most commercially available DEF is listed as 11 degrees. Cold, yes, but not THAT cold. If you’re heading south from Minneapolis for a long vacation in the sun, and your Motorhome has been parked for an extended period of time prior to leaving, and it’s January, there’s a good chance your DEF tank is frozen solid. The good news is that your Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) system is designed in a way to heat the tank and lines to full thaw prior to engaging the transmission. The SCR will enable you to start your engine with a frozen DEF but you may be waiting an extended period of time for it to fully thaw. Dealing with it once before heading to Florida probably won’t be a problem, but for those four-season travelers who like to head north (Canada, for example) it could be a frequent annoyance.

There are other concerns. Many owners claim the introduction of a new, complicated and critical system to the simplicity of the diesel engine makes the added expense of a diesel less appealing versus a traditional gas engine. Some claim the DEF systems adversely affect fuel efficiency, power, and maintenance costs while others insist DEF improves these items.

Here at RVReviews.net most people tell us the driving experience between a pre-DEF and a DEF Motorhome is unnoticeable and that the maintenance and monitoring of the system, while an added burden, soon becomes just another part of owning a Motorhome.

How about you? Do you have a DEF story or opinion of your own? Drop me a note at John@RVReviews.net and fill me in. Interesting or informative comments will be shared with the group next week. If you want to share with me the story of the guy who peed in his DEF tank in the desperate hope that it would get him to the next filling station, please don’t. I’ve already heard it about five times and, no, it didn’t work out very well for him, from what I heard. Stories about traveling with your own pig are strongly encouraged, however.

Filed Under: RV Articles Tagged With: Motorhome DEF

About MrRV

My Cart

Free RV Report

“The book is excellent! Used it as a guide and reference. Went to the Toronto RV Show with 4 RVs in mind, based on the research you provided. By the 2nd day we purchased a Fifth Wheel. With your book on my IPad in hand, we asked the right questions and it greatly aided us in our final decision.”
Paul T.
“I thank you for your assistance, prompt reply, and the report, which is very informative and provides just the info we were looking for to make our choice.”
Kelly T.
“Thanks for the excellent RV Review Report. It supports my research and reassures me that I’m looking at the right unit for my intended use. Your PPI is on my check-off list of needs before I finalize my purchase (probably July or August). It’s been a pleasure working with you. Your RV info products and reviews will be #1 on my list of recommendations for any potential RV buyers I meet on my travels.”
Mike W.
“Thanks for the book and report. Your product was very informative and valuable, with a lot of information for the price.”
Jim M.
“I just want to take this time to thank you for writing the Motorhome Comparison Guide as well as the “How to Save Thousands” report which I downloaded prior to buying the comparison guide. I learned much more than I thought I would and I am now confident that I will be prepared when I do finally buy my first RV.”
Patricia D.
“After digesting your very informative Travel Trailer and Fifth Wheel Guide, I did something I have told others I would NEVER do.  I purchased a NEW fifth wheel. After finding the “perfect” unit, I did the research as explained in your guide, and stuck to my guns as you prescribed, and made the purchase.  I honestly believe I saved several thousand dollars by reading your guide. Using your Comparison Guide and the other “free stuff” you provided, made the experience a fun one.  I would definitely  recommend your guide to RVers.  It paid for itself many times over!”
Gary D.
“Thank you for writing all the useful articles and books that really help older folk transitioning to this type of lifestyle.”
Conrad and Evelyn C.
“Thanks to what we learned from your books we were able to find the RV that had the best ratings we could afford and we were able to negotiate to the dealer’s bottom line and saved a few thousand dollars.  I can say your product is up there with one of the best hundred dollars we have spent.  It was easy to read and understand and helped us as we looked at each RV to know where to look and more importantly what to ask. We found that the dealers were not very willing to volunteer information.  On the other hand, when they realized we knew what we were talking about they were very forthcoming.”
Tom and Catherine M.
“I bought several of your guides over a year ago and just purchased a new Motorhome. Your material was of great value to me. First in determining which RV to buy and then in the purchase of the RV. I would have never guessed that we could purchase a brand new RV at XX% off the list price, had I not read your material. We have had the RV about two weeks now and are having a blast with it. We plan on spending 4 months in it this summer.”
Alan F.
“We enjoy reading your books and newsletters. We need good objective unbiased information.”
Larry R.

Can’t Find What You Need? Search For It!

Blog Categories

  • RV Articles
  • RV Models
  • RV Reviews
  • Uncategorized

Article Archive

  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • December 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • November 2016
  • September 2016
  • July 2016
  • May 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • October 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • December 2014
  • September 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013

Logo

Recent RV Articles

4 Top Tips: Buying an RV during a pandemic

The next two months will be the best time to buy an RV -ever.

Bucket List Destinations:

Coronavirus vs. America

Back in stock: The 2020 Travel Trailer & Fifth Wheel Comparison Guide

Like Us On Facebook

SiteLock
SiteLock
  • Affiliate Area
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use

Copyright © 2021 Brought to you by JR Consumer Resources Inc. · Sitemap